As a dog owner, you already have the best plush toy in the world. It’s warm and furry, it squeaks, plays, and it’s always down for a snuggle. Sure, it also keeps stealing your snacks, but doesn’t your pup deserve a treat for being such a good furry friend? A brand-new plush toy perhaps?
If you’ve already bought one or two before, you already know it’s a tough process. Is the cute bear or even cuter panda better? Should you purchase one with or without a squeaker? Will it even last for more than 5 minutes? And, most importantly, will your pup like it?
To save you the trouble (and money), we’ve gathered the seven best plush dog toys on the market. We considered durability, stuffing, size, and, of course, cuteness when making our picks. Read these reviews before you make your final decision—your pup will thank you for it!
In this article
A Quick Look at Our Favorites in 2025
| Rating | Image | Product | Details | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Best Overall
|
|
Kong Floppy Knots Dog Toys |
|
CHECK PRICE |
Best Value
|
|
Outward Hound Invincibles Geckos Plush Dog Toy |
|
CHECK PRICE |
Premium Choice
|
|
goDog Action Plush Gold Fish Squeaker Toy |
|
CHECK PRICE |
| Best for Puppies |
|
HuggleHounds Plush Squeaky Dog Toy |
|
CHECK PRICE |
|
Bones & Chews Rope Whale Crinkle with Bone |
|
CHECK PRICE |
The 7 Best Plush Dog Toys in 2025
1. Kong Floppy Knots Dog Toys – Best Overall
| Material: | Polyester, synthetic fabric |
| Features: | Squeaker, knotted rope inside |
| Toy size options: | Small to medium |
| Breed size: | Small to medium |
We picked a classic for our best overall plushie. From the makers of the popular Kong toys, this one is also designed to keep your pup entertained for hours. The Kong Floppy Knots has an internal knotted rope to keep those puppy teeth busy instead of gnawing on your arm or shoe. All four paws are knotted, and the center is filled with a squeaker.
There are four different characters to choose from: fox, bunny, elephant, and hippo. This toy is made of synthetic fabric and polyester fiber fill, so it’s durable, especially with the tight stitches. Since it’s on the smaller side, it’s ideal for puppies and small breeds.
The fabric is also designed to be gentle on your pup’s gums. We like how there are different textures and colors on this plushie, from the smooth tummy to the spiral arms. The minimal stuffing also means there won’t be a mess in case your dog tears it apart.
We can see this plush toy becoming a quick favorite in your home. If you’re looking for a quality and durable stuffed animal, this is the one to get.
- Durable construction
- Interesting textures
- Several features in one
- Various size and character choices
- Lack of stuffing may bore some dogs
- No large option
2. Outward Hound Invincibles Plush Dog Toy – Best Value
| Material: | Dura-tuff polyester |
| Features: | 2 or 4 squeakers, no stuffing |
| Toy size options: | Small and large |
| Breed size: | All dog breeds |
Outward Hound’s Invincibles Geckos is one of the best plush dog toys for the money. The name gives a clue—these little guys are designed to be long-lasting, even for the most vigorous chewers.
These lizards have two jumbo squeakers that keep working even if they’re punctured. They’re also made with Outward Hound’s proprietary dura-tuff lining—a super-tough fabric that’s reinforced with double-layer seams. This makes the toy extra durable and resistant to chewing.
Like most plushies on our list, there’s no stuffing here for your dog to pull out. The bright colors are also eye-catching, and we like that there are different sizes to choose from: the two-squeaker smaller version and the four-squeaker larger one. Either way, you’re getting a quality toy that will last for a long time. However, the design is a little plain for some preferences.
- Reinforced stitching
- Squeakers still work when punctured
- Small and big options
- Plain design
3. goDog Action Plush Gold Fish Dog Toy – Premium Choice
| Material: | Polyester, synthetic fabric |
| Features: | Animated, squeaker |
| Toy size options: | Regular and large |
| Breed size: | Small to large dog breeds |
The goDog Action Plush Gold Fish Animated Squeaker Dog Toy is for spoiled pups who deserve the best of the best. This premium plushie comes to life when your dog plays with it, just like a real fish! We also like that it doesn’t need batteries. It’s chomp-powered, meaning your pup’s bites make it move. There’s also a squeaker inside to engage their hunting instincts even more.
Inside the colorful synthetic fabric is a heavy-duty lining that makes it last longer than standard plush toys. Finally, the goDog Action Plush Gold Fish is still super soft, so your pup can cuddle with it when they’re taking a break from playing. While this toy is extra durable, it also means that it comes at a higher price tag.
- Interactive fun
- No batteries required
- Long lasting
- More expensive than other toys
4. HuggleHounds Squooshies Squeaky Dog Toy – Best for Puppies
| Material: | Polyester and synthetic fabric |
| Features: | Squeaker |
| Toy size options: | One size |
| Breed size: | All breeds |
The HuggleHounds Squooshies Durable Plush Squeaky Dog Toy is our top pick for puppies. It’s made with extra soft and luxurious velveteen fabric, so it’s gentle on those growing teeth and gums. This toy also has Tuffut Technology exclusive to HuggleHounds. It’s a three-layer lining design that makes it durable enough for teething dogs.
There are squeakers inside for added fun, and the overall design is meant to be as cute as it is durable. Aside from using it as a teething toy, you can also use the HuggleHounds Squooshies to teach your new buddy how to fetch or play tug-o-war. However, the smaller size might not be ideal for larger dog breeds.
- Gentle on the gums
- Soft but durable
- Cute designs
- May not be tough enough for bigger breeds
5. Bones & Chews Rope Whale Crinkle with Bone
| Material: | Cotton canvas, rope, and real bone |
| Features: | Bone, internal water bottle, rope-textured body |
| Toy size options: | Large |
| Breed size: | Small to medium breeds |
If you’re looking for a plush toy with a little bit of everything, check out the Bones & Chews Rope Whale Crinkle with Bone Dog Toy. It boasts three unique textures, including real bone, classic rope, and cotton canvas so your pup can explore different sensations while playing.
Around the whale’s tail is a 1.5-inch bone from a water buffalo. Aside from being fun to chew on, it also doubles as a dental toy to help keep those teeth clean. The rope is good for interactive games of tug-o-war, and the cotton canvas is soft and wonderful for snuggling.
Another unique feature of this plush toy is the recycled water bottle inside instead of the usual squeaker. Plus, it gets bonus points for being eco-friendly and quiet while offering your dog a satisfying crunch. However, the bone may be too hard for some dogs with sensitive teeth.
- Three unique textures
- Bone tail doubles as dental chew
- Eco-friendly
- Bone may be too hard for some
6. Frisco Hide & Seek Plush Volcano Puzzle Dog Toy
| Material: | Polyester |
| Features: | Squeakers, puzzle |
| Toy size options: | One size |
| Breed size: | Medium to large breeds |
The Frisco Hide & Seek Plush Volcano Puzzle Dog Toy offers a fun challenge to help keep your pup’s mind active. The toy has two parts: a soft volcano with holes and six squeaky dinosaurs.
You need to stuff the dinosaurs into the volcano, and then your pup has to figure out how to get them out again. It’s a great way to help them burn off some energy and use their noggin at the same time. For a fun boost, the dinos also come with built-in squeakers. The fact there are six dinosaurs means the toys still work even if your pup loses one.
When your pup’s not trying to retrieve the dinosaurs, they can cuddle up with the plush volcano for a nice nap. However, some dogs might not have the brain power to figure it out. The small dinosaurs could also be a choking hazard for bigger dogs.
- Mentally stimulating
- Plush volcano is great for chewing and cuddling
- Small dinos can be potential choking hazard
- Some dogs don’t enjoy puzzle games
7. Multipet Bouncy Burrow Buddies Dog Toy
| Material: | Polyester and rubber |
| Features: | Squeaker, internal ball |
| Toy size options: | One size |
| Breed size: | Toy to small dog breeds |
The Multipet Bouncy Burrow Buddies Baby blends two dog favorites in one: plush toys and fetch toys. Inside each Bouncy Burrow is a small, round ball that makes the toy bounce and roll all over the place.
Your pup will have a blast chasing it, and you’ll get a good workout too! Thanks to the internal ball, this toy also floats, making it ideal for water-loving pups. For an extra layer of fun, Bouncy Burrow Buddies also have squeakers that are activated when the toy is squeezed.
For an extra layer of fun, Bouncy Burrow Buddies also have squeakers that are activated when the toy is squeezed. You can choose from several furry options like a raccoon, squirrel, beaver, skunk, fox, and opossum.
- Plush toy also works for fetch
- Different animal designs
- Not recommended for bigger breeds
- Not very durable
- Not suitable for larger dogs
Buyer’s Guide: Selecting the Best Plush Dog Toy
Buyer’s Guide: Selecting the Best Plush Dog ToyThe best part about buying your dog a new toy is seeing their face light up and tail wag upon giving it to them. However, as a pet parent, you’ve got to take your job seriously. If you don’t buy your dog the right kind of toy for their breed, it could become torn apart in a matter of minutes or potentially become a choking hazard. So, what things do you need to look for?
The Importance of Play
Besides being a bonding moment with your dog, playtime gives your dog plenty of physical and mental stimulation to keep them active and healthy. First, the more you can work your dog’s mind, the smarter they become. This leads to a happier and healthier dog all-around. Second, exercise is a must when owning a dog. Even a short game of fetch is known to improve their overall physical abilities. Third, giving your dog toys reduces the change of behavioral issues. Do you like when your dog chews your new shoes? We didn’t think so. Buying them a new toy is a great way to cure boredom.
Why Use Plush Toys?
If you’ve got a larger dog breed at home, you may be wondering why you would buy a plush toy in the first place when there are plenty of other, more durable toys out there. For starters, plush toys are a gentler form of entertainment. Your dog, hopefully, isn’t going to knock a lamp over or hit the TV screen when throwing around their plush toys.
Another thing to consider about plush toys is that they act as a sort of companion for your dog. If you only have one dog in the house, life can get lonely when you’re not at home. Giving them a plush toy that they love becomes a sort of comfort for them.
Plush toys also come in a variety of shapes, sizes, and textures. While softer toys that are easily chewed aren’t always the best for larger dogs or aggressive chewers, they are gentle on puppy and senior teeth that are a bit more sensitive.
Our Selection Process For Best Plush Dog Toys
To create this buyer’s guide, our writing team and editorial staff checked customer reviews, brand reputation, and veterinary approval ratings to present the plush dog toys we think should be highlighted for our readers. In some cases, we conducted hands-on testing along with seeing how much our dogs liked the plush dog toys. All these factors were considered when selecting these listed plush dog toys to help you make the best purchase for your furry friends.
Why Trust Dogster?
Since 2004, Dogster has been a trusted brand for dog owners online, which means we have a lot of experience with plush dog toys. We take pride in promoting the well-being of all dogs—from toy breeds to giant canines. Our in-house veterinarians, writers, and editors examine each product on our lists, ensuring its quality and reputation. As pet owners ourselves, we only want the best for our furry companions. At Dogster, we are transparent about the products we promote. The nutritional information, overall brand reputation, and customer reviews are all considered for these lists. We inform you how we want to be informed.
Final Thoughts
For the best overall plush dog toy, the Kong Floppy Knots combines durability, fun textures, and built-in squeakers in one durable package. The Outward Hound Invincibles Geckos delivers a tough, long-lasting toy that’s perfect for aggressive chewers, while any dog will go crazy for the animated goDog Action Plush Gold Fish.
In all cases, these top three plush are a terrific addition to your dog’s toy collection. They provide hours of fun, whether your dog is playing fetch, tugging on a rope, or just cuddling up for a nap.
- You may also be interested in: 12 DIY Fleece Dog Toys You Can Make Today (With Pictures)
Featured Image By: leks quintero, Unsplash
